Tuesday, February 1, 2011

My shy boy

I signed Noah up for the Mini-Movers class for toddlers.  Its an active, tumbling, gym sort of class... basically a fun class to get toddlers moving around.  Eli started this class a week after his second birthday and really loved it.  (Here's a post from over two years ago when Eli was in the class...)  I try to keep things pretty equal and give Noah the same opportunities Eli had, so when Noah turned two I thought about signing him up.  He didn't seem quite ready for it, (as he seemed to not enjoy other kids... the whole being rough thing...) so I waited until now.  AND... he doesn't really like it.  He refuses to hold anybody's hand for the circle time, he turns his face away when the teacher talks to him, he whines when I try to get him to do the hand motions, he stands stiff and rigid when the kids are supposed to be hopping, jumping, marching, spinning or running, and he is glued to my side- and that is only when he isn't requiring me to HOLD him.  :)  It's so funny because he's an active little guy at home, and lately he's been SO talkative.  

Its weird having a kid that has a, what seems like, total opposite social personality than my first kid.  With Eli we had to tell him NOT to hug the grocer, with Noah we want him to at least say hi to someone who's slightly familiar.  Even in his classroom at church, he mostly keeps to himself and doesn't interact with the other kids.  I don't know if he feels shy or intimidated or just doesn't care because he's got a best friend at home.  I try to encourage him by saying things like, "Noey, are you gonna play with J.J. in your class today?"  And he replies with a very friendly, "I play with nobody!"  What am I supposed to say to that!?  If he ever talks about other friends, its always Eli's friends.  Its always about Eli.  I feel bad and don't want Noah to live in Eli's shadow, but it seems like that's where he feels comfortable for now.  

Then there are times when he is so sweet and friendly to other people... and it throws me for a loop and leaves me scratching my head.  Last week we had a play date, (with one of ELI'S friends) and his baby sister came.  She's about 15 mos old and kinda wobbly walking around.  Noah was so interested in her.  He kept bringing her toys, asking if she was okay every time she fell, and constantly returning her blanky to her when she dropped it.  He'd gently pet her head and give her kisses.  It was adorably sweet!  
I'm not sure what to expect of him.  I have a really shy nephew, and when I'm around him I just sorta keep my distance until he feels comfortable.  I used to do that in the preschools I worked at too.  I would never force someone to answer my question, sit in my lap, hold my hand, etc.  I would interact with other kids near them, so they could make their own observations and decide to join in or not.  But everything feels different when its your own kid.  What do I do?  Or do I do nothing, and wait for him to step out?  Should I keep taking him to the class?  Should I keep providing social opportunities unless he hates it?  What about the rule, 'you have to speak when your spoken to'? Is that more appropriate for older kids?  Should he have to hold a friend or relative's hand if he doesn't want to?  Its tricky because he's both shy and stubborn-- is he using his shyness as an excuse to be stubborn?  If we push him because we think he's being stubborn will it make him even more shy?  Any suggestions?

Here's a couple videos of what he's like in class.  The second one is funny because he finally began to participate when she brought the bubbles out, and then all of a sudden he was shouting, "BAM!  BAM!  BAM! .... Mommy!  Mommy!  Mommy!"  

Oh, and Eli was a crack up.  I knew Noah would be shy, so for our first day I told Eli he was going to have to sit with the mommies and make sure Siah was okay in his stroller.  He confidently strolled Siah in and sat over with the moms while I carried Noah in.  I looked over Eli's way during the class a few times and saw him giving Siah kisses, fixing his blanket, or giving Siah his bink.  He even got my camera out of my purse and decided to take some pictures (at the top of this post).  And for a lot of the activities, he was participating from his seat.  :)

5 comments:

Sintari said...

Hey, Jessie!
That last paragraph about Eli being the responsible big brother is so cute! Way to go, Eli!
It doesn't sound to me like Noah is living in Eli's shadow. It sounds like he's just a different type of kid - someone who's comfortable playing by himself, and uncomfortable in big groups. I don't know many 2-year-olds who have made their own friends. Usually if children this young have friends, it's because their parents are friends and they spend a lot of time together by default. So I wouldn't worry about the no-friends thing! :)
One or two of my kids are definitely slower to warm up in most social situations. Lately, I've been seeing a great improvement in their anxiety levels in group settings, so I definitely think that if anxiety is Noah's issue, it can be partially overcome. On the other hand, he may also just be an introvert (which is different from being shy), and that's more of a personality type, not something to overcome. :)
When you're out and about, and Noah doesn't say "hi" back to the grocer, or won't hold someone's hand or give a hug to a relative, I would just let him be. Maybe say hi for him or say, "No, I guess he doesn't want to give hugs right now," no apologies or explanations. Help him feel as comfortable as possible. Feeling comfortable and confident - not like there's something wrong with him - will help so much in his overcoming his anxiety.
One more thing - I would try not to let Noah hear you refer to him as "shy." Labels can have a negative effect on kids - they can start to internalize that description and feel even more uncomfortable when they behave outside of the box of who they identify themselves as being. Does that make any sense? :)
One thing we do at school is, Reid will whisper to me in class, things he'd like to say to the teacher. I'll say it for him (even if it's "Reid wants to tell you that we're renting Star Wars from Netflix!" in his math class...) and then the teacher replies to him and he sort of gets to practice talking in public, without having to actually open his mouth and risk embarrassing himself. Lately, he's been saying more and more things out loud all by himself!
Just keep on being Noah's advocate, help him along, set the example, and he'll do great. :)

Jessie said...

Thanks for your comment, Amy! I'm always interested in what you have to say about kids because child development seems to be a passion of yours. I am definitely passionate about my kids but don't do nearly as much reading on their development as you do. (Maybe I should!)

I do think Eli & Noah have different personality types, but I never differentiated between introvert & shy. I've always used the two words synonymously, but I think you are so right. Even extroverts can be shy at times or in certain situations. Interesting!

Also, I'm sad to say I have used the word shy in front of him... enough times that I learned the lesson myself when he told me he didn't want to do something because he was too shy. Ugh! Ooops!!! I've been trying not to say a whole lot about their personalities in front of them. Unless its stuff like being kind to someone else and that sort of thing. (behavior stuff)

I've been talking for him in his class, which works good, but I was starting to wonder if it would have the opposite effect and make him not want to talk if I'm always doing it for him. So its encouraging to hear its working well with Reid. I think I spoke occasionally for Eli when he took the class, too. I can relate to that one, because I hate talking in front of groups of people I don't know. :) (Sometimes even groups of people I do know.)

The interactions with other people is a hard one. There was a situation 5mos ago when someone wanted Noah to hold her hand. He shook his head no, and she persisted (by grabbing his hand) not 1, 2, or 3 times, but 6 times!! He finally pulled his arm away kinda aggressively, and she responded by saying, "Oh, Stubborn!" Of course I freeze in those situations. In shock of what's going on, I stumble over my words or say something that's not exactly fitting. I think that was one of the times I said, "He's just being shy." I need to think of things ahead of time, so I can be prepared! :)

Goodness, this is wonderful & challenging all at the same time. I wonder what Josiah will be like! :)

Sintari said...

Ugh! I hate those situations! That used to happen with Ruby, especially at the hospital. She'd be scared and nervous and quiet, not giving eye contact, appearing very rude to the nice nurses. I would feel so embarrassed and even get frustrated with her when nurses would comment on her attitude. I tend to care too much about what other people think. Not that behaving rudely is okay, but I think I forgot to give her some lee-way and advocate for her, considering the amount of stress she was under. :(

Michelle said...

Oh, I sure do know what it's like to have a kid with a personality that leaves you scratching your head! Changing my perspective made all the difference and gave me a new appreciation for all personality types. Instead of thinking of Joshua as crazy and hyper, I think of him as creative and enthusiastic. :)

Stubbornness can be a great quality to have. I can think of a few instances in our childhood, when Amy's stubbornness helped her stick to her convictions and do the right thing, while I folded and followed the crowd. Maybe instead of considering Noah as stubborn, consider him as determined, persevering, and persistent. I bet the Noah of the Bible had a lot of those traits, too, to continue building the ark while everyone laughed at him and acted like he was crazy.

Along those same lines, it might be that your Noah just isn't interested in being a people-pleaser. I'm probably not around him enough to know, but I don't think of him as shy. It might just be that he doesn't need everyone's approval/friendship, which again, can be a good thing. Peer pressure probably won't be much of an issue for him. If he's happy playing by himself, I don't really see why he needs to make friends, especially since he already has a best friend.

If he really is shy, I can tell you that as a very shy kid, whenever people tried to "fix" my shyness, it made me feel like they were saying my personality wasn't good enough. Of course, that just made me withdraw even more. Just keep modeling polite social behaviour, and I'm sure he'll follow suit when he's ready to be more social.

The fact that he was so sweet with the little girl who came over to play, shows that he knows how to make a connection with someone when he's interested. So, it sounds like he's not lacking social skills, he's just more choosy about who he's making connections with. He's got good instincts about that, too. He realizes that being sweet with a little girl in his own home is safe, but hugging strangers in the grocery store can be unsafe. That kind of ties into the thing about holding hands when he doesn't want to. In my opinion, kids should always have the option of saying no to physical contact, even if it's just giving Mommy a high-five. I don't want them to ever feel like they have to let someone touch them, just for the sake of being polite.

Jessie said...

Thanks, Michelle! I love hearing stories about Joshua's creative personality. He sounds so entertaining!

I never connected the determination thing with Noah from the bible- that's so good! I'm always praying he'll have faith like the Noah we named him after, but never realized he seems to already have the determination. :)

I agree with the physical contact thing. When Eli was a baby (about Josiah's age and older) I had a hard time with people wanting to hold him seconds after walking into a room. How scary for a little guy- to leave the safety of Mommy's arms to suddenly be face to face with someone he doesn't know.

Thanks for your encouraging words. Its nice to step back and get some feedback from an outside perspective.

I sure wish we could all get together more often!